

Why We Need a Trans-Only Online Community
By Michelle Herman, Founder, Trans Alliance Network
Trans, non-binary, and gender-diverse people need a verified, trans-only online community. The reason is simple. Safety and trust are preconditions for learning, support, and growth. Open networks cannot guarantee those conditions. A trans-only space can. When we remove constant vigilance, we make room for connection, skill building, and mutual aid. That is not exclusion for its own sake. It is a targeted design for a community with specific risks and goals.
The Problem We Live With
Many of us spend our days navigating isolation and low-trust spaces. Policies shift. Misinformation spreads. Community resources fracture. The result is predictable: declining mental health, burnout, and less access to care. I have watched this pattern repeat across cities, age groups, and identities.
We've all heard the chilling tales of people in our community facing harassment and mockery simply for expressing themselves online. It's a stark reminder of the darker side of digital life that many endure.
This is the cost of open venues. Vulnerability becomes searchable content. Safety becomes a gamble.
What a Verified Community Changes
A verified, member-led space changes the equation. Verification sets a clear boundary at the door. Trained moderators set norms inside. Members know the rules. Kindness is the standard. Harassment is not tolerated. There is an incident response path. There are timelines. There is accountability.
Boundaries are essential; they are a vital part of our infrastructure. They safeguard our energy, prevent harm, and enable long-term participation.
In practical terms, this means responding to issues within twelve hours or less. It involves having a clear escalation process, removing harmful posts swiftly, and creating an environment where individuals don't have to "prove they belong" in every discussion. Ultimately, it fosters trust among participants.
Learning Requires Psychological Safety
Learning is a social process. People need to ask "basic" questions. They need to test ideas. Individuals need to share their draft identity narratives openly, without the fear of facing adverse consequences online.
I remember reading the powerful narrative of an older trans woman, and in her words, I discovered a profound reflection of my own feelings. She articulated what I had been grappling with, accurately expressing emotions I had struggled to put into words. Her candid account resonated deeply with me, illuminating my experiences and validating my journey in a way I never expected.
In open spaces, those conditions rarely hold for trans people. A bad-faith reply can shut down inquiry for months. A dox can end participation entirely.
In a trans-only community, education is one of the pillars. Trainings, live webinars, and resource guides meet members where they are. The format is accessible. The culture is clear. We design for growth and retention. We use weekly rituals and monthly challenges to compound progress. We prioritize essential outcome metrics, including weekly active members, 90-day retention rates, and member satisfaction. Additionally, we monitor moderator response times and hold ourselves accountable to high standards.
This community thrives as a vibrant classroom, fostering growth with clear guidelines, a strong code of conduct, and a well-structured plan to guide our journey together!
Support Is a System, Not a Slogan
Support is another essential pillar. It encompasses peer-led groups, mental health check-ins, and professional referrals. In a trans-only space, support is not random; it is scheduled and facilitated by trained individuals who provide a safe and supportive environment. There is a clear process in place to prevent burnout, along with established boundaries and a backup system to provide additional support when needed.
Over the last few years, as anti-trans headlines have spiked, our collective anxiety has increased significantly. I've noticed that many online friends have shared small tips on what has helped their mental health. What we truly need are systemic, organized, and practical approaches to support one another.
Connection, Culture, and Action
Connection goes beyond social interactions; it also has practical implications. Private networking groups enable members to connect with peers who share similar career paths, health journeys, or creative pursuits. Smaller settings make it easier to seek help and create leadership opportunities. Members can attend events, participate in challenges, and find resources. When connections are made, action follows. Advocacy efforts become more coordinated, and collaborations begin to form. Our culture supports this approach, fostering open dialogue, active listening, and mutual respect. We do not reward put-downs; instead, we value care and clarity.
The Economics of Belonging
A trans-only community requires a sustainable funding model. Free access is crucial, as not everyone can afford to pay. Offering a free tier helps build trust and expand our reach. A community tier can help fund our operations, while an organizational tier allows trans-led partners to collaborate with us in serving and learning together. Scholarships and discounts help ensure that access remains open to all. Transparent pricing eliminates pressure and confusion. This approach allows us to sustain our community without selling member data or attention.
Sustainability is part of safety. When a space relies on ads, outrage becomes a growth hack. When a space depends on member value, we optimize for belonging and utility.
Addressing Common Objections
"Isn't exclusion divisive?"
Designing for a specific group is not a moral judgment about others; it is a matter of understanding their needs and preferences. It is an admission that context matters. Many communities have identity-specific spaces. Women's shelters. Black student unions. Deaf clubs. These spaces exist because safety and shared experience produce outcomes that general rooms cannot. Trans-only spaces do the same.
"Won't this limit conversation?"
Limits foster depth. In a community focused solely on trans issues, we spend less time debating our right to exist and more time addressing the actual problems we face. While we welcome a variety of perspectives on strategy, care, and identity, we establish a baseline of respect and a limit on harm.
"What about allies?"
Allies are essential to us. Many will partner with us as supporters and resource providers. A trans-only community does not exclude allies; rather, it clarifies their roles and responsibilities. There are some spaces where allies should not lead, and specific conversations that are not meant for allies to observe in real time. Establishing these boundaries protects the intimacy necessary for growth. We still value our allies, and they can continue to support our success.
Design Principles That Make It Real
A trans-only community works when we honor a few principles.
- Verification first. We verify members to protect identity and trust.
- Moderation as care. Trained moderators hold the room. They follow clear playbooks.
- Programs with cadence. Weekly programs and monthly challenges keep momentum.
- Metrics with meaning. We track activity, retention, satisfaction, and response times.
- Minimal data. We collect only what we need. Consent is clear. Removal is honored.
- Member leadership. We invite members to host, teach, and shape culture.
- Accessibility. We design for different capacities and bandwidths. Camera-off is valid. Text-only is valid.
- Privacy as a promise. We do not exploit vulnerabilities for marketing purposes.
These are not abstract values. They are operational choices.
What Success Looks Like
Success is not defined by "going viral." True success is when someone logs in each week because they feel a sense of belonging. It's having a moderator who can step back without the community falling apart. It involves a partner who sponsors a training program because it effectively reaches the right audience. Success can be seen in a dashboard that displays healthy participation and steady retention. It is a culture that supports individuals during tough weeks and celebrates growth during the good times.
So We Are Doing It
We are creating a community for us, by us, called the Trans Alliance Network, or The TAN. This is a safe online space built on six foundational pillars.
- Education: Trainings, live webinars, resource guides
- Inspiration: Member stories, spotlights, guest speakers
- Support: Peer-led groups, mental health check-ins, safe spaces, professional referrals
- Action: Advocacy, challenges, collaborations
- Connection: Networking calls, local meetups, shared interests
- Culture: Develop/maintain a culture of open dialogue, active listening, and mutual respect
We are establishing a paid advisory board, comprising community experts who will oversee key aspects of our programming and offerings. Each member will undergo a gentle human verification process to ensure the safety of all participants. This means that every participant, whether a director, advisory board member, sponsor, or organizational representative, will identify as part of the transgender community.
Call to Action
We can keep asking open platforms to become what they are not. Or we can build what we need. A verified, safe, member-led network where trans, non-binary, and gender-diverse people connect, support one another, learn, and thrive. Education. Inspiration. Support. Action. Connection. Culture. Real programs. Clear safeguards. Sustainable membership.
If you are transgender or non-binary, this is your invitation. Your questions matter. Your space is respected. Your story matters. Join a space created for you. Then, help make it welcoming for someone else.
Connect. Support. Learn. Thrive.
Join the waiting list (below) now to receive a 50% discount on your first six months of paid membership!
Register for the Waiting List!
Join the waiting list now to receive a 50% discount on your first six months of paid membership!
Together, we are stronger. Together, we thrive.
© 2025 | The Trans Alliance Network, All Rights Reserved.
